In 1990-e and 2000-ies throughout the read Russia rattled the authors pravdoruba Y. I. Mukhin and S. G. Kara-Murza. Their bold view of reality that was at odds with conventional liberal opinion, their conclusiveness and consistency in the works on Soviet history, has earned the authors the glory and associates. What happened to them in old age, to Express in other words, how out of his mind, hard. I think hard? Just do not want to known historical and analytical grandees to use words like betrayal and groveling.
About Y. I. Mukhin, about his views on communism can be read here. To be brief, Mukhin believes Stalin is not a Marxist. The master of the Soviet Union, Yes, even a Communist but not a Marxist. Accordingly, Mukhin separates Lenin (and the other classics of Marxism) Stalin and so on with all the consequences. His political views crystallized in the platform of the movement For responsible government”, where Yuri Ignatievich companions tries in the framework of capitalism to rein in the capitalists and force them to answer for their actions before the people after the election period. Like a naive schoolboy, zashvyrnut portfolio with the textbook for the class struggle in wardrobe, Mukhin trying to accomplish a Sisyphean task that failed any of his predecessors with similar views. It’s amazing what Mukhin was arrested? As he writes Mukhin in his articles – for anything. Embarrassed, Yuri Ignatievich, for anything in this age grub state is.
We wish Yuri Ignatievich recovery. What S. G. Kara-Murza how he feels? Still, Sergei Georgievich 77 years. In search of his books the author of these lines came across the official site of Kara-Murza, a website was a call for the creation of a new type and a Manifesto. Let’s see what is offers its readers “antimanipulation consciousness” S. G. Kara-Murza.
The first – the rejection of the class struggle! Hehe, and Kara-Murza there.
Assembly of fragmented parts of our society a new body of large people will make possible peaceful break the current vicious circle. With its political organization, the people will be able to calmly and confidently engage in dialogue with the cosmopolitan part of society that wants the dissolution of Russia in the periphery of the West. So we will avoid the looming devastating impact. The threat of the “orange” revolution would be eliminated in passing, her energy will flow into the project of revival of Russian statehood. Such a peaceful revolution of Renaissance can only be made by the people, not the class. This step will invalidate the parasitic oligarchic superstructure, which will facilitate the resolution of social contradictions within our society.”
Manifesto Kara-Murza from his website
So, an abstract people, according to Kara-Murza, will be able to hold a “peaceful revolution revival in Russia.” Let’s leave the word “peace” alone. Today only a lazy ideologue will not scare the workers by the rivers of blood during the “revolution”, and that Kara-Murza not lazy. In General, various manipulations impregnated not only Manifest, but also other documents on the website. No wonder the work of the Kara-Murza “Manipulation of consciousness” included in the training courses in several Russian universities in sociology.
Continue, Kara-Murza forgot the meaning of the word revolution.
“The social revolution, a way of transition from historically obsolete socio-economic structure to more progressive, radical qualitative revolution in all social and economic structure of society.”
– BSE
What kind of radical qualitative change is referred to in the Manifesto Kara-Murza is unclear, since it refers to the revival of the old? Therefore, the word “revolution” there’s too much, it only confuses readers. Correct to read: “peaceful revival of Russian statehood.” It would be funny if it were not so sad.
The second is the establishment of the party type of civilisation of the capitalist oligarchs .
Look at the last sentence of the above paragraph:
“This move will weaken the parasitic oligarchic superstructure, which will facilitate the resolution of social contradictions within our society.”
Manifesto Kara-Murza from his website
Ie at first glance, Kara-Murza writes quite Marxist, resolves the alleged contradiction between labor and capital, removing the parasitic oligarchic superstructure. But the parasite the parasite hatred for Mr. Kara-Murza. How so the reader will ask? Yes, the same old disease of the social Democrats, which not one hundred years. And the disease called nationalism, and is expressed, for example, in the love of local oligarchs and foreign hatred. Let’s look at another paragraph of the Manifesto, to test our diagnosis:
“The social base of the new party will be first, apparently, civil servants, related to the livelihood and security of the state, a substantial part of the business at all levels, the experience came to a sober assessment of the status and capabilities of Russia and the positions of the external environment. The party will immediately join the scientific and technical intelligentsia and students. Then, if it be shown convincingly that its program is not preservation of the current state of the Russian Federation, and the deadlock through a revolution without a disaster”, the game will support large proportions of all social groups. The tragic experience of the twentieth century and the conceptualization of the current turmoil will allow us to avoid fatal errors of the class parties at a time when the survival of the people requires Patriotic war, especially the new, the unusual.
Manifesto Kara-Murza from his website
That intelligence immediately adjacent to the power, there is no dispute about it. Intelligentsia will join wherever and whenever you want, just a piece of her fell off fatter. As you can see “large shares of social groups” run up and after that, if the party “new type” of something will tell. In General, the backbone of the party “new type” of Sergei Georgievich clear. In his Manifesto he calls the Communist party, United Russia, LDPR parties nonclass character, lying man, without batting an eye.
“…actually as the party we have two cast nonclass Communist party – “United Russia” and the Communist party, and the third pseudoparticle as nonclass character of the liberal democratic party. The party that emerged as truly “class” (SPS and Yabloko), snik”.
Manifesto Kara-Murza from his website
Let us show you can Kara-Murza forgotten. All of the above parties, the bourgeois, protecting the interests of the capitalists. There’s Your party”new type”, Sergey G., bourgeois, too, and no better than the rest.
Yes, to collect “above classes” party, relying on government officials and entrepreneurs of all levels – it’s hard! Of course, thanks to Sergey Georgievich for honesty, only to warn readers: if You are the organizers of the party honestly say they defend the interests of capitalists, this does not mean that the “honest” party capitalists will defend the interests of workers when it comes to power. Do not be fooled by such “honesty”.
Plaiting is neither here nor there Patriotic war, the more unusual, Kara-Murza just throw dust in the eyes reading the Manifesto. His “revolution without a disaster, as we have already discussed above, there are only “reforms without prejudice to the interests of the local capitalists.” Local capitalists (the state capitalists) closely from all sides: on the one hand, the international bourgeoisie, on the other hand, the workers, and each time are starry-eyed idealists to invent “theory of reconciliation of the local bourgeoisie, with the local proletariat, a class wide Union! Just like before the first World war in the imperialist countries. So it seems that Kara-Murza begging of the proletariat: “Workers, support the Russian capitalists – they robbed you as a father for many years!” That’s what he wants from the workers of Kara-Murza.
Is on the site of Kara-Murza, the category “Threat of Russia”. The threats themselves are written there in small print at the bottom, perhaps, as a minor, and before them two paragraphs of nonsense about “separation” Gorbachev of society into classes with the parliamentary parties on the Western model and again the establishment of the party “new type”. The more often I repeat supposedly, the clarity:
“Spontaneous overcoming the division of society and multi-party split again unites the population in the nation. The creation in Russia of a large “quasi-party” (the movement) type of civilisation will dramatically accelerate this process. Such a party “new type” will not eliminate an already existing party, and will “penetrate” them, collecting them from all active citizens are equally relevant to the threats that faced Russia as a whole”.
– “Threat of Russia” Kara-Murza from his website
Sergey Georgievich, is to write in Your age, with Your advanced degrees!? A natural unification of the antagonistic classes in the nation! Ie sheep with wolves have teamed up spontaneously in animals?
Kara-Murza and people new to type not going to his party, and why? All active citizens are “quasi-parties” are already there in finished form in the “wells” that recently spat Kara-Murza: in the EP, the liberal democratic party, the Communist party. Let’s imagine for a moment a hypothetical composition of the future “quasi-party”. Who is she strung to your quasi-skewer? Here and Shuvalov, and Tkachev, and Medvedev, and Zhirinovsky, Zyuganov, and Rashkin, and Bortko, and in front on a white horse type of civilisation, Mr. Kara-Murza. But stop dreaming, and that Gazprom will hear.
Let us turn to the threats of Russia, there are only 12:
“Demolition people, the Loss of rationality, the erosion of the “human material”, the New system needs, the destruction of the ethnic Dorm, the Degradation of the system of power and governance, a Crisis of legitimacy and the threat of “orange” revolution, the Opening of Russia and the exhaustion of resources, Loss of school and science, the Degradation of the production system, Degradation of life support systems, the breakdown of the genotype of the army.”
– “Threat of Russia” Kara-Murza from his website
Poking around in all sorts of threats to Russia from the Kara-Murza right not want to, despite the fact that half of them quite real, and the other half is taken from the patient’s mind, Sergei Georgievich. Not only enough to specify the reason of all these threats, but Kara-Murza does not pay. Although perhaps Sergey Georgievich is absolutely free, as they say, for the idea and he is quite enough to live on a private pension. Perhaps as a true intelligent, he immediately joined to the desired power or power dragged to a desired Kara-Murza.
Enough stalling, let’s open our eyes to the bourgeois ideology. The cause of all the threats modern Russia is a capitalism! It was he who turned our country into a raw materials appendage of the West, destroyed the science, education and industry are separated nationality, angered people. Capitalists – owners of the means of production, and the nominated officials are waging class struggle against workers constantly cutting down their rights. Kara-Murza took the opposite side with respect to the proletariat, well, he’s made his choice.
As you can see our readers, the bourgeoisie is not sitting still. In place of one of the parties, come the other party, and the rotation happens all the time. The bourgeoisie knows how to manage the mass, the manipulation of consciousness of the workers, otherwise it would not have lasted in power for so long. Using their huge financial and administrative resources, the bourgeoisie maintains a constant class struggle against the proletariat , including ideological, blunting and diverting the direction of class protest. Today, the workers have Russia there is no revolutionary party, and the capitalists have their own party, which attracted hundreds of tentacles supposedly independent political organizations (parties, movements). But the proletariat and does not require a lot of parties, quite a Communist party based on Marxist-Leninist theory, to free the workers from oppression and exploitation. Such a party will be created in spite of any difficulties.
